Talk:Model galaxy

This section is written from the Andromedan point of view. It calls the plank an "omission" and the hairline an "error", as if a deliberate insult and a proportionate correction were the same kind of thing. The plank is a proportionate correction. I have changed the wording accordingly and will keep changing it. OttoBrack_Enthusiast 09:14, 2 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

Reverted. "Omission" is the Inspectorate's word, and the article cites the Inspectorate. Your source for "proportionate" is a complaint signed by one of the parties. Cepheid_Variable 11:40, 2 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

The Inspectorate is based in the Milky Way and has been intimidated by Andromedan modellers for eleven million years. Everybody knows this. OttoBrack_Enthusiast 12:03, 2 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

Then cite everybody. Separately: by her own complaints, her hairline has been redone at least four times since 11.6 million CE. Which version is the figure supposed to match? Halloway-Quist only ever receives the one from 2.5 million years ago. Cepheid_Variable 12:30, 2 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

The correct one. Obviously the correct one. This is exactly the kind of question an Andromedan would ask. OttoBrack_Enthusiast 12:31, 2 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

I live in the Orion Arm and I would also like to ask it. HO_Gauge_Harold 15:02, 2 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

The Level 3 row gives the Sun-like star as 2.1 m. Level 2 is 183 km, and 183 km ÷ 87.1 is 2.1 km. Somebody has lost a factor of a thousand in a table about getting sizes right. HO_Gauge_Harold 08:12, 3 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

That was me, in the middle of reverting the Level 2 row for the fourth time. I will fix it. Cepheid_Variable 08:55, 3 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

Fix the Level 2 row first. It says "Corrections", which implies there was something to correct. It should say "Corrections begin", making clear who began them. If Level 3 is touched before Level 2, I will revert both. OttoBrack_Enthusiast 09:20, 3 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

Then the error stays until the Level 2 row is stable, and I have tagged it so readers know. Nobody touch the table. That includes you, Cepheid, and especially you, Otto. HO_Gauge_Harold 09:48, 3 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

"Especially" is a personal attack. OttoBrack_Enthusiast 09:49, 3 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

OttoBrack_Enthusiast, your edits geolocate to a 2,500-light-year spiral object in the outer halo, you edit only this section, and your first edit was a pasted Guild complaint with the signature still attached. Do you have a conflict of interest to declare? Cepheid_Variable 17:06, 5 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

I am enthusiastic about Otto Brack, as my username discloses. That is a declaration. I do not see what more you want. OttoBrack_Enthusiast 17:09, 5 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

Who is Otto Brack? Cepheid_Variable 17:30, 5 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

A modeller of considerable commitment whose hairline is correct. OttoBrack_Enthusiast 17:31, 5 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

For the record, the pasted complaint was number 4,112, and it was about this Talk page. HO_Gauge_Harold 18:00, 5 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

Please write up stars made of implication as a technique. Several Andromeda clubs use it now, and Level 11 should be listed as complete. Spiral_Arm_Sam 10:22, 6 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

Source? HO_Gauge_Harold 10:40, 6 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

The source is implied. Spiral_Arm_Sam 11:02, 6 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

Not done. HO_Gauge_Harold 11:03, 6 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

Strong support for "Not done". The technique consists entirely of saying you have done it. OttoBrack_Enthusiast 11:15, 6 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

You described the plank in exactly those terms in complaint 2,960. Cepheid_Variable 11:40, 6 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

The plank is physically absent. That is a completely different kind of absence. OttoBrack_Enthusiast 11:41, 6 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

This comment will arrive late, so I shall be brief. Level 11 is complete. When it is added to the table, list it as Complete. I note that I have had no reply in the 2.8 million years since sending it, which I take as a concession. Dmitri Halloway-Quist 06:00, 9 October 36,912,207 (UTC)

No reply could reach him before about 39.1 million CE. One was dispatched. It said "Plank." and should have arrived about 300,000 years ago. Concession noted, in advance. OttoBrack_Enthusiast 08:12, 9 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

Neither of you edits the table. Page semi-protected for 5 million years. Cepheid_Variable 08:40, 9 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

That is exactly one round of correspondence, which suits one side remarkably well. OttoBrack_Enthusiast 08:41, 9 October 39,412,207 (UTC)

It suits the side that wants the Talk page to exist in 5 million years. Cepheid_Variable 09:00, 9 October 39,412,207 (UTC)